CAL 136_legaldramas Alex Schwartz: This is Critics at Large, a podcast from The New Yorker. I'm Alex Schwartz. Naomi Fry: I'm Naomi Fry. Vinson Cunningham: And I'm Vinson Cunningham. Each week on this show, we make sense of what's happening in the culture, not now, but right now, and how we got here. How you guys doing? Naomi Fry: Great. Doing well. Vinson Cunningham: Good. You know what's fun? You don't get it so often anymore. Naomi Fry: Hmm? Vinson Cunningham: A season of TV that lasts, like, 20 episodes. Mm-hmm. You know, like, long TV seasons. Naomi Fry: It's ... I, I miss it every day. Alex Schwartz: You gotta go to the networks. Vinson Cunningham: Network. Isn't it... It's just like, y- you sit there, guest stars, you go with the changes. It's really fun. Alex Schwartz: That's it. Vinson Cunningham: Here's a show that fits the bill. It's called Cupertino. This is the new series, uh, from the showrunning team Robert and Michelle King. You, if you don't know their names, you know at least of their work. They're behind, uh, The Good Wife, The Good Fight, and they're masters of a particular [00:02:00] form that we're gonna talk about today, the legal drama. Their new show, Cupertino, centers on this Silicon Valley law firm. These lawyers are working for the underdogs of tech, the Davids to the great big corporate Goliaths. Naomi Fry: Mm-hmm. Vinson Cunningham: There's some other legal stuff stirring, another legal drama that I've been liking. It's on HBO. It's called War, about a high-profile divorce in London. It feels like a moment for the legal drama. What do you guys think the appeal of this genre is? Why do we love it so much, if we love it so much? Tell me. Naomi Fry: I mean, it's, I think first of all it's like crime and punishment usually. Vinson Cunningham: Mm-hmm. Naomi Fry: Or if not punishment, at least some form of resolution. You know I’m thinking about that famous Atticus Finch scene in the movie To Kill a Mockingbird, and it shows this idealism about the role courts play in society. CLIP: To Kill a Mockingbird There's a sense that like there's order- Mm-hmm ... in the world, in a world that's often feeling more and more disordered. Vinson Cunningham: Yeah, yeah. Alex Schwartz: That's interesting that you say [00:03:00] that because I think often it can be, yes, order, but it can be a little bit the opposite as well. I mean, there is the law and order side of it where someone does something bad and then they're prosecuted. Mm-hmm. But then there are a whole host of movies and shows where the interest is in showing the state's overreach or wrong assumptions- Mm about people, and the thrill is in watching someone get off and be proved innocent or more details come to light. Naomi Fry: Right. Alex Schwartz: I think on a very basic level it's also just about antagonism. You have antagonism built into this thing. Mm-hmm. You have protagonists, you have the prosecutor, you have the defendants, you have conflict, you have a process by which secrets will be revealed, and you have storytelling because most legal dramas deal with trials. And yes, there are exceptions, including on Cupertino where settlements happen and, and such things occur. Vinson Cunningham: Mm-hmm. Alex Schwartz: But we love to go to the courtroom to see stories get told. Vinson Cunningham: That's right. So we're gonna talk about that today, Cupertino, and we're talking [00:04:00] about why trials on screen and off have become such a particular fascination, maybe even obsession for audiences today. I gotta say, I'm really excited for this episode because we're having a very special guest, a member of the New Yorker staff who we almost never get to hear on mic. I don't know if he's ever been on this kind of, you know, podcast mic, but he's uniquely qualified to talk to us about this genre. I seriously cannot wait. So that's today on Critics at Large, Cupertino, War, and the order of the courtroom. ________________ What are the ingredients of the genre? What's like a must-have thing, the essentials? Naomi Fry: Well, of course a courtroom scene or scenes. Vinson Cunningham: Mm-hmm. Naomi Fry: Right? Vinson Cunningham: Yes. Naomi Fry: I mean, the drama that goes down in the procedure In the courtroom. Mm-hmm. You know, objection sustained. Over- Overturned. Yeah. You know, all of that. Overruled. Overruled. See- Overturned. See, I don't even, I don't even [00:05:00] remember. But, you know- ... the, the objection thing, I just feel like that is such a m- mainstay, you know? Vinson Cunningham: Objection Naomi Fry: sustained. Sustained. Bang gavel, you know? Alex Schwartz: Yeah, the drama of the courtroom itself, absolutely. Mm-hmm. I would say, um, quirky lawyers. Lawyers who- Oh, yeah. And getting into the background of the lawyers often on a legal drama. Naomi Fry: Mm-hmm. Alex Schwartz: Mm. These aren't faceless schlubs. These are people with personalities. Maybe the show or the movie wants us to identify with them. Maybe they're w- we, we love to hate them. Maybe they just do some really weird stuff, like, um, Jimmy Stewart in Anatomy of a Murder, the 1956 Otto Preminger movie, which is set in Michigan, and he just, um, makes, uh, fishing, fly fishing flies- Uh-huh the whole, as he's sitting- ... and listening to the prosecution, and then jumps up and, and gets incendiary and goes back to his, his fishing preoccupations. Naomi Fry: A bit eccentric. Alex Schwartz: A bit eccentric. Vinson Cunningham: We call that stimming now. I don't know if you know that. Alex Schwartz: Ah. Right. Absolutely. Vinson Cunningham: That's what that's [00:06:00] called. Um, yeah. There's also a sort of, especially if it's a TV show and it's happening over and over again, a kind of procedural, you need stories that are kind of ripped from the headlines. Mm-hmm. You need really familiar stories that kind of maybe ended ambiguously in life, and you can finally have, like, adjudicated on TV. Naomi Fry: Mm-hmm. Vinson Cunningham: I like that, too. Naomi Fry: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Uh, you know, research, g- going over the files, you know- The files ... the, like, deep into the night. Vinson Cunningham: Mm-hmm. Naomi Fry: Uh, you know, I mean, that's even in some, some texts that aren't, like, you know, legal dramas per se. Like, in Clueless, right, her dad is this brash, like, Hollywood lawyer, right? Yeah. CLIP - Clueless And, uh, and he's like, you know, sitting there going over, like, "Don't bother me." You know- Yeah. ... just, like, the crabby lawyer is another, the crabby, like, partner. Vinson Cunningham: Crabby lawyer, yeah. Naomi Fry: Yeah. Vinson Cunningham: Usually there's, like, an older lawyer and a younger lawyer. Mm-hmm. And the older... And the way that the audience is taught about the minutiae of the law as it pertains to the case is by the older lawyer burning the midnight oil, telling the younger lawyer, [00:07:00] "No, it's this," you know? And so that, that, there's a sort of, like, also didactic element in that, in that scenario as well. Do you have favorite TV lawyers? Alex Schwartz: I mean, my favorite TV legal series far and away is The Good Wife. Vinson Cunningham: Okay. Alex Schwartz: Mm-hmm. So I'm just gonna put that out there. And therefore, there are many favorite lawyers on The Good Wife. That show ran for one billion years. Yeah. Mm-hmm. It had 1,000 episodes. Mm. I watched every single one of them. That's great. But let me just speak to Will Gardner, played by Josh Charles. Okay. Will Gardner of, um, Lockhart Gardner, the law firm at, at the heart of The Good Wife. CLIP: The Good Wife There's an arrogance, like a really appealing- arrogance to Will Gardner. Mm-hmm. But he's young and handsome, and so it's not like the old, grizzled arrogance of someone who's been doing this for a million years, and a kind of clarity and assurance, and a bit of a, he, [00:08:00] he, he likes a, a game of pickup basketball, He's having a thing with Alicia Florrick, the main, the protagonist of the show, played by Julianna Margulies. Will Gardner, shout out to you. Naomi Fry: Yeah. I mean, for me, like, what kind of, like, cemented my feelings and opinions about not only the legal drama but also the law is, of course, L.A. Law, the Steven Bochco-produced, uh, series that ran from '86 to '94. CLIP: LA Law Naomi Fry: That wonderful team of hot lawyers that- ... populated that office, you know? Starring Harry Hamlin, Jimmy Smits. Alex Schwartz: How did it make you feel about the law? Naomi Fry: I was like, "This is sexy." I was a child. Vinson Cunningham: Yeah. Naomi Fry: But it's, we'll talk about this more, but, but that is- Yeah ... you know, it kind of, yeah. Alex Schwartz: That's what they want you to think. Naomi Fry: Right. Vinson Cunningham: My favorite since childhood is a f- fellow named Ben Matlock- Naomi Fry: [00:09:00] Mm Vinson Cunningham: from the show Matlock. Naomi Fry: Mm-hmm. Vinson Cunningham: Originally played, now there's a new version of it that's out. Naomi Fry: Mm. Alex Schwartz: Which is gender-switched, right? Vinson Cunningham: Is it? Alex Schwartz: I think Vinson Cunningham: so. I don't even know enough about it. It's Naomi Fry: Mrs. Matlock? Alex Schwartz: I, well, it's- ... it's, yeah, I'm pretty sure. Yeah. Yeah, it has, um- Ms. Ma- ... it has Kathy Bates ... Naomi Fry: Ms.- Ms. Matlock. Alex Schwartz: Kathy Bates as Madeline "Maddie" Matlock. Vinson Cunningham: There you go. Naomi Fry: Esquire. Vinson Cunningham: The original had, uh, Andy Griffith. CLIP: Matlock When I was a kid, I thought the TV was mostly a vehicle to deliver Matlock. Man, old Black ladies in, in both New York and Chicago, man, they love Matlock. And, um, he introduced to me, like, a special trope, which is, um, the sort of genteel Southern lawyer. Alex Schwartz: Mm. Vinson Cunningham: Mm. He was like, uh, he had been, I think, educated up North, but he opened up this practice in Atlanta. He was kind of gruff but folksy with a heart of gold, you know? Um- Alex Schwartz: Was he a lawyer of the people? Vinson Cunningham: He was a defense lawyer. Alex Schwartz: Yeah. Vinson Cunningham: So he had all kinds, he was often, a, a lot of the stuff, 'cause it's, like, not unlike a lot of l- [00:10:00] legal shows, it was also covertly about his business. You know? It's like, who he would waive his retainer for. Yeah, yeah. Usually, like, you know, the people. He would, like, begrudgingly take on pro bono cases, et cetera, et cetera. Um, but, uh, I just thought, uh, this goes to what Nomi was saying before, is it's like there is an avenue for justice. It is imperfect, but this guy, there are g- people like Matlock who are just always with his gray suit on. It left an impression on me. Naomi Fry: Okay, you guys, so we've talked about our favorite lawyers on screen, our favorite legal teams on screen, and now we are going to hear from our favorite lawyer in real life, and possibly my favorite employee of The New Yorker. It's revealed here, Fabio Bertoni. Fabio. Fabio. Vinson Cunningham: Hey, Fabio Bertoni: everybody. Vinson Cunningham: Fabio, as we know, but our listeners, maybe they do if they're, like, real, like, deep New Yorker heads. I don't know. Maybe they know, but I don't think they know you are the general counsel at The New Yorker. Yes. Can you just explain for us before we even get into [00:11:00] the rest of this what that means? What do you... What- what's your domain around here? Fabio Bertoni: Um, first of all, I am so, so, so happy to be here. Uh, I love this show. Aw. It's a childhood dream to be on this show. And I think I've told each of you separately that it's one of the things that we do at The New Yorker that I have these real strong, visceral thoughts about every time I listen to your show. Mm. And, uh, and on occasion I've emailed Vinson to- to let him know my thoughts, and he's extremely graciously ignored all my emails. So- Oh Naomi Fry: my God, Vinson Cunningham: Vinson. We talk in person about it Fabio Bertoni: regularly. Vinson Cunningham: Don't take it personally. And I'm Naomi Fry: also so happy- Fabio, if you email me, I'll respond ... Fabio Bertoni: sometimes I get- He's not a man of email. No, no, no. So yes, I am, I am the general counsel, which, uh, means that, um, all legal issues for the magazine, uh, come through me. Vinson Cunningham: You make sure none of us get in trouble. That's like the... That's my favorite thing that you do. So, okay, moving on to the world of entertainment, what to you is a good legal drama? Fabio Bertoni: So there's a couple of things. I mean, [00:12:00] there are courtroom dramas, and then there are sort of legal procedural, uh, things. And in a courtroom drama, oftentimes, uh, the- the procedure's totally botched and it's just cartoonish, and it's- And it really as a lawyer, uh, knocks me out of it. Doctors must have this with medical shows where it's just gobbledygook, and it just doesn't mean anything, and it's just very frustrating. Vinson Cunningham: Yeah. Is there a show... 'Cause it, the, for example, like The Pit, you hear a lot of doctors being like, "Actually, they kind of did it." For you, what are the shows that you, you watch it and you can, you can, you can ride with it because they do some work of verisimilitude? Fabio Bertoni: So the, the one that, um, lawyers talk about is, uh, My Cousin Vinny. Interesting. Naomi Fry: Yeah. Fabio Bertoni: My Cousin Vinny gets the procedure really correct. Yeah. And there's a lot of the, a lot of the drama is about, um, like, expert witness testimony. Uh-huh. CLIP: My Cousin Vinnie They do it really accurately, and it's, and it's hysterical. Naomi Fry: Fabio, you're talking about My Cousin Vinny, the 1992 comedy about a murder trial. That's interesting that a comedy gets it more right than many dramas. Fabio Bertoni: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I, I can talk about what my favorite ones are, but- Please The Verdict, uh, Paul Newman. Vinson Cunningham: What's, what's that... Can you give, give us a, a Fabio Bertoni: premise of- So he, he is a broken man, alcoholic. Uh, there's this phenomenal opening scene of him in a bar early in the morning, uh, drinking a beer and playing pinball. And, uh, and it's just, uh, it's just such a gorgeous movie. [00:14:00] Um, he gets this one case about, um, a woman at a Catholic hospital, CLIP: The Verdict Naomi Fry: What in that makes it, like, a, a good legal drama movie? Fabio Bertoni: Okay, so here's my... I, I have a theory. I have a- Oh, good. Um, I should, I should say that I have big lacunae in my legal watching life, but of the ones I have seen, um, I've come up with this theory, which is that the really compelling ones capture something very specific about being a lawyer. Law is inherently a really difficult thing because any reasonable lawyer, any thinking [00:15:00] lawyer, is constantly terrified that they have not been diligent enough- Vinson Cunningham: Mm-hmm Fabio Bertoni: and that they haven't been thorough enough, and maybe they're not smart enough. And law also has this really, you know, infinite grade- gradation of hierarchy and, um, authority. Authority is inherently really important to the profession. The Supreme Court outranks the dis- the- Mm ... the appellate court, which outranks the district court, and, and that's reflected in all kinds of things that lawyers do and, and think of. And so, um, that feeling of insecurity and terror and inadequacy is really central to being a lawyer. Vinson Cunningham: Mm. Fabio Bertoni: Um, and I think a lot of- For me, really powerful dramas, but also comedies, capture that in some way, that you're really unsure. Vinson Cunningham: Yeah. Fabio Bertoni: And the self-loathing and the terror- ... um, sit right next to each other. Um, but also that if you [00:16:00] win, it's in- it's incredibly redemptive. It's like this feeling like, "I did one true, good thing." So The Verdict gets that. Naomi Fry: Mm-hmm. Fabio Bertoni: Um, you know, the Paul Newman character is just, uh, it's, it's just heart-wrenching. CLIP: The Verdict and it's got that arc of self-loathing and inadequacy, but also in the end, redemption through, through law. Yeah. Personal redemption. Naomi Fry: Mm-hmm. Naomi Fry: Fabio, do you like any TV legal dramas? Fabio Bertoni: So- Um, uh, I thought The Night Of was really good. Naomi Fry: Oh, yes. Alex Schwartz: Um- I actually don't know The Night Of. What is it about? Fabio Bertoni: It's about a kid, Naomi Fry: Yeah, played by Riz Ahmed. And, Fabio Bertoni: yeah. Yeah. Great, great performance. Um, and he's accused of a murder that he didn't commit, but really appears bad. Naomi Fry: Yeah. Fabio Bertoni: John Turturro plays a defense lawyer, CLIP: The Night Of You know there's a lot of self-loathing and, and they probably over-indexed for it a [00:18:00] little bit- ... 'cause he's got, you know, uh, these- He's got, Naomi Fry: like, eczema ... Fabio Bertoni: he's got eczema on his feet. It's really disgusting. He's like- He picks at his feet ... he's, like, shuffling the, the- He, like- He picks at his feet. Um, but, but as a character, and of course, John Turturro's a phenomenal actor. So good. He, he, um, presents it, um, you know, the, the, the humanity of this guy so well. Alex Schwartz: So Fabio, why do you think that legal dramas fascinate wider audiences and people who have no experience with the law? Fabio Bertoni: I mean, again, because, because, um, it's a classic narrative, right? There's a, there're two conflicting stories. There's, there's often a good guy and a bad guy. A- and a courtroom is a set, right? Right. There's a, there's a stage. There's an audience. There's, you know, and then there's also the back- the backstage. There's the judge's chambers. There's the law offices and all these things. And, and so people sort of come together for this performance that is good versus [00:19:00] evil, truth versus lies. Um, and, and it can play out. Vinson Cunningham: Well, we have a test case, and we'd like to, we're gonna talk a little bit more about this show, but we'd like to get your at least short take, initial take on the new CBS show Cupertino. Fabio Bertoni: Mm. Vinson Cunningham: Your, I see your faces already, so- ... I d- I wanna know where it lands on this scale of kicks you out of it, you can stick with it. Cupertino. Fabio Bertoni: So I got through half an episode of Vinson Cunningham: it. Alex Schwartz: You said, you said it all. And there, and there came the verdict. Fabio Bertoni: As, as a lawyer, I build .5 hours to- ... watching- Vinson Cunningham: Yeah ... Fabio Bertoni: Cupertino. Vinson Cunningham: Fair, you know what? Fair enough. Fabio Bertoni: Yeah. Vinson Cunningham: We're gonna get into it more. Fabio- Fabio Bertoni: Wait. Please. One, one other thing. Please. Yes, please. One other, I, I really wanna shout out, um, uh, J. Cameron Smith's, um, uh, role as Gerri on Succession. Oh, she's so good. Oh, great call. So good. She's so good. So good. That's a great call. So good. And for, for the record, if there's ever a movie made [00:20:00] about The New Yorker, uh, I want J. Cameron Smith to play me. Naomi Fry: That's Vinson Cunningham: awesome. Fabio Bertoni: Thanks, Fabio. This is so much fun. This was awesome. This was awesome. So glad to be here. Thank you, guys. Vinson Cunningham: When we're back, we get to Cupertino, a very ripped-from-the-headlines approach to an old school format. This is Critics at Large from The New Yorker :: MIDROLL:: Okay. Thank you again to Fabio Bertoni. That was fantastic. Um, but now that we've gotten the lay of the land a bit once it comes to legal dramas as a broad thing, let's go back to Cupertino. It started airing in October, and in true network fashion, this is not a binge, right? You gotta watch it week by week, and all 20 of them, uh, in the fullness of time, will be there not only on CBS, but on Paramount Plus, uh, for streaming. Can somebody please give us the setup? Naomi Fry: Vincent, can I just say that I love when you say, "In the [00:21:00] fullness of time"? Vinson Cunningham: Uh, yeah, I know. Naomi Fry: I always, I always look out for that. It's so Alex Schwartz: comforting. Naomi Fry: I know. It's so comforting. I'm like, tell me, tell me what's gonna happen. In the fullness of time. In the fullness of time. Yeah, thank you. Uh, okay, Cupertino. So we have, we are in Silicon Valley. We have a lawyer named Michael Price, played by Mike Colter, who has just been fired from his job as a partner in an AI startup. And, uh, it transpires that he has been fired so the, his co-founder will avoid paying him his equity. Meanwhile, another younger associate la- lawyer at the firm, a young woman named Olivia, played by Rachel Keller, is also fired. It transpires that she was sexually harassed, uh, by that same co-founder. And these two decide to band together and, uh, establish a firm that [00:22:00] will not serve the interests of the, what they call the Goliaths. Mm-hmm. You know, the, the, the kind of like, uh, uh, enormously wealthy, uh, Silicon Valley founders, but the people who have tangled with them, who have been hurt by them- Yeah ... in, in some way. And, uh, from there proceeds, you know, this procedural where a bunch of things happen. There are some recurring characters, but there are also specific kind of stories that happen, um, to represent this kind of legal gambit. Vinson Cunningham: Alex, what did you think? Alex Schwartz: It's not good. Um, I wanted it to be good, and even continually insisted to my husband that it would become good. Naomi Fry: He's like, "When?" Alex Schwartz: I just wanna publicly apologize to that man, uh, 'cause it didn't get good yet. I've seen four episodes. Mm-hmm. I'm behind where it's airing, but my problem with it is that it's extremely didactic to a point that l- has lost all interest for me. The point of the show is [00:23:00] tech sucks, people who work in tech suck. I mean, I'm not contesting it. Yeah. I'm, I'm, I'm part of the choir. Like, yes, go ahead, Cupertino. But I didn't find anything to be particularly interesting or revealing. For example, there is a case, there is some of the ripped from the headlines stuff. Mm-hmm. Um, there's a case in the third episode where there's a chatbot who has apparently instigated a young tween boy to kill his own father. Naomi Fry: Yes. Alex Schwartz: The boy is now on trial, and the defense, the, the team of, um, Michael Price and Olivia Cifre are trying to prove that the chatbot bears responsibility for this. Mm-hmm. And we know of many very disturbing cases about people and their contact with chatbot, um, often involving young people and self-harm, but I didn't think that anything fresh was being brought here, and Fabio's point before about legal procedure, I as a non-lawyer am willing to let things slide as long as there's some kind of rough go at a semblance of verisimilitude. Vinson Cunningham: Sure. Alex Schwartz: But this, this just skips so many of the steps that it's barely plausible that these things are transpiring in a courtroom, or that opposing counsel would not have anticipated some of these challenges, any of it. And there's none of the texture of a show like The Good Wife, which was also created by the Kings- Naomi Fry: Mm-hmm ... Alex Schwartz: um, that really kept me watching. With The Good Wife, from the start, there were things that seemed a bit outlandish that I initially rolled my eyes at, but you get into it because the [00:25:00] characters are beautifully drawn, the tensions, the interpersonal tensions between the lawyers, the kind of big law atmosphere of this law firm where all the, the young summer associates or, or, or first year associates are anxious about whether they're gonna be taken on as second year associates, needing to prove your stuff, the way that the judges interact with the different lawyers and test them out. Those elements were all there, and what the Kings did a really good job of, I think, on The Good Wife, was incorporating those contemporary issues, and actually especially the issue of tech. There were some early examples of just the dominance of the tech world- Mm-hmm ... into court cases that were quite interesting. And here it feels like picking at stale stuff that's been in the culture for a while. Mm-hmm. That's my feeling. You guys tell me what you think. Vinson Cunningham: It's interesting. It has been in the culture a while, and yet, I don't know, it just feels like there's not a lot of stuff actually dealing with- At least in the provinces of art entertainment, this side [00:26:00] of our lives that we're struggling to deal with. Um, it just seems like there's almost like nobody wants to do these parables about the very recent past or the, like a concurrent histories. It does seem like it's attempting to fill a certain void. Um, another sort of thing, of course, like, like many of these shows, there are the short-term one case an episode, et cetera. Lots of guest stars, people that you recognize kind of flit through. I was like, "Oh, that's Busy Philipps," um, et cetera. Um . Um, but there are some, some, some things that sort of start to weave themselves throughout the season as well, and one of them is, I don't think it's a spoiler alert to say that one of the, quote-unquote, "clients" is in fact an AI itself. Bo, this like AGI, um... What does AGI stand for? Naomi Fry: Hmm. Vinson Cunningham: General- Artificial ... ju- artificial general intelligence. General intelligence. Like, it's like- Yeah ... so it's the thing that we're all worried about existing that can, like, make its own decisions and whatever. I [00:27:00] don't know, turn off the power grid or- Mm-hmm drop a nuke or whatever the fuck it's supposed to do. Um, here it is, you know? And, um, sort of realizing this otherwise pretty much like bodiless terror that exists in the culture right now. So the relationship to the material, it's interesting. I was like, I've read a lot about this, but I haven't seen it represented them. It's, so it's weird, like. Alex Schwartz: But do you like the way in which it's represented? Vinson Cunningham: Well, it's weird. Okay. So the... I think I like it a little bit better than you guys do Um, I like the way that it sort of like, uh, creates some distance from the genre, at least like formally. There are all these weird above head shots which make me think about the logic of surveillance, which becomes, it's something that gets reiterated every once in a while, how many cameras there are everywhere. A lot of like, uh, the, the, the, the lawyers early on are working out of this diner and they're, they're filmed as if like from a CCTV camera, and like the, the color grading is kind of strange. It like, it looks almost like, [00:28:00] uh, it's always the golden hour- Mm-hmm ... in this version of- Mm-hmm ... Silicon Valley. Naomi Fry: Mm-hmm. Vinson Cunningham: And like the blues are like- Actually Naomi Fry: shot in New Jersey, I believe. Vinson Cunningham: Really? Naomi Fry: Yeah. Vinson Cunningham: The blues are like very blue, and some of the production d- design is very, it's not Wes Anderson, but it is very much like matchy-matchy with the costumes in a certain way. Um, there is a sort of surrealism, and in this way it, it, this is stuff that's been done before. I'm thinking about the, the show Silicon Valley on HBO, the, the, um, the comedy, uh, Silicon Valley. Mm-hmm. There's like, every time there's like a service worker or somebody filing, um, serving somebody a lawsuit or anything, the, the per- the person says, "Oh, you know, I got a pitch deck on this and that." Like- Yes the, the sort of like cartoonishly opportunistic grasping nature of Silicon Valley is joked about in a way that's n- a- actually kind of happening maybe a little bit. But, um, something about the look of the show and the pacing of the show makes me think that it can, like I'm, I'm still, I'm gonna watch a couple more episodes. Fabio Bertoni: Hmm. Vinson Cunningham: And I, I kind of, I think that we need [00:29:00] s- some vehicle for the absolute absurdity of the news from this part of the world to like, to come through. I think we need that vehicle, and I'm hoping this show can become that. Naomi Fry: I, I guess I feel [00:30:00] like, I mean, I feel several thi- Alex, I think I agree with you on a lot of what you said, the sort of rabbit out of a hat feel of, of the solutions that are being reached, you know, um, on this show. On the level of plot, like I found it both wooden and highly accelerated. It's just like everything is like bam, bam, bam. Oh, you're fired? You're hired. You're- You lost the case? Oh, actually you won the case. Yeah, yeah. You know, like, oh, you listen to a song? You have an idea for like a brilliant idea for your defense, you know? Yeah, yeah. It's like everything is kinda, everything happens for a reason you know? Yeah. And everything happens, like extremely quickly without letting anything marinate or develop organically. Yeah. And I understand, like that is the challenge or one of the main challenges of legal drama is that, yeah, things take time. But there is something, too, additionally, with the kind of the culprit of AI, the culprit of [00:31:00] tech. It's we are at an extremely chaotic time, right? Yeah. Like we don't know what's happening, and things are talking about acceleration, things are really being accelerated beyond all measure such that we don't know what will happen in the fullness of time. Yeah. Right? There is no comfort. Yeah. And I think there is a sense that we want, in some senses, one of the things we want from legal drama is to create order from chaos, as we said, or comfort from discomfort. Something about the kind of like the AI of it all- Mm-hmm ... and the kind of, like, how much we don't know about it in real life heightens the kind of like too quick pat-ness of the show. How it res- Vinson Cunningham: resolves on Naomi Fry: the show. How it resolves on the show, and how like many, many, many steps were skipped in a way that maybe not believe in the universe that I was watching. And when we are doing ripped from the headlines, like big like almost life and death stuff, or like future of humanity stuff, then [00:32:00] I'm like, "I'm gonna watch this if it's gonna give me some, I, if not satisfying, then at least thought-provoking, believable answers." Vinson Cunningham: Yeah. Alex Schwartz: Vinson, even if you continue with Cupertino, your heart is a bit divided because- Mm-hmm. Yes ... we know that you've been watching War- Mm ... the new HBO legal drama. Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Um, and I would love to hear a bit about it, since I've not yet had a chance to see it. This is a show that you've really been liking. Vinson Cunningham: I do, I do like it, and I think I'm gonna write about it, so, uh, we'll see, uh, whether that will appear on newyorker.com. Um- "War" depicts the, in, in the sort of fine grain, the divorce between two very prominent people. Uh, one is a tech mogul played by, uh, Dominic West, who I, I like Dominic West so much. I feel like- Alex Schwartz: Who doesn't? Vinson Cunningham: Yeah, I mean, he's like- McNulty. McNulty from The Wire. He's the, the troubled writer Noah Solloway in the, the show [00:33:00] The Affair. I don't know if you ever saw The Affair. Oh, Naomi Fry: yeah. Oh, Vinson Cunningham: yeah. Um, he's great. So every, anytime I see him, I'm in. He, uh, in this case- Naomi Fry: Talk about a destroyed man. Vinson Cunningham: I know. He's, he's got that sort of, yeah, ruined brilliance. Naomi Fry: He- Gin-soaked, gin-soaked- Vinson Cunningham: Exa- There you go ... Naomi Fry: you know? Vinson Cunningham: In this case, he plays, again, a tech mogul who, uh, runs a social media site. He created a social media site, and at least his self-concept is that he's, like, the sort of moral tech guy. Like, you, we see him, like, winning an award for this at, at the very beginning. Um, and on the other hand, um, is Sienna Miller, who plays a model, actress, who, uh, is married to the Dominic West character. And he's been unfaithful in the past. At the first episode, she, we, we come to know that the, the woman that we see him sleep with after this awards ceremony was a honeypot- Mm ... sent by the wife. Naomi Fry: CC Jensen. Vinson Cunningham: And so there's a little, a li- and this is, and I saw this before Jensen Huang. Mm. So there, there's a lot [00:34:00] of, speaking of the headlines, this was almost prophetic, okay? It's, it's not, it's not the Chinese government, but still, a honeypot nonetheless. Um, and this starts the war that is the divorce. Mm-hmm. They show up at an event together, and because he knows that she's gonna divorce him, she has her served for divorce on the red carpet of this event that they're both together. So boom, and it's about the two teams of lawyers. So it, while focusing on the two major personae of the, of the divorce, it also becomes this sort of, like, uh, ensemble thing on both sides with the lawyers and their, you know, their maneuverings and, uh, dubious ethical moves, all this stuff. Um, and it's really about, it really is about, in the end, the, the lawyering, the, the, the fighting, you know. Uh, and of course, here, a huge fortune is at stake, and you see all the things that money can bring to bear on a, on a very, like, [00:35:00] high-profile case. I like it. It's fun. Naomi Fry: I think, you know, s- I, I haven't watched "War," but something that it brings up to me, the way you're describing it, is just the The one of the options in a legal drama, or one of the m- possible attractions, potential attractions in a legal drama is the legal drama soap opera, right? Vinson Cunningham: Mm-hmm. Naomi Fry: And there's also, you know, the recent Ryan Murphy show, All's Fair, uh, that just the, the second season just, just came out like last month, where it's about kind of, uh, um, much like The Good Fight, a, a woman-only law firm staffed by, uh, you know, women like Kim Kardashian, Glenn Close. There is their enemy from another law firm, Sarah Paulson. Mm-hmm. You know, it's all these divas who are populating this, this legal world. Right? And, uh, [00:36:00] the whole thing is just an excuse for spats- ... and hookups- Right ... and over-the-top outfits- Great ... and ostentatious luxury, and just like, you know, women spitting in each other faces and, and pulling each other's wigs or weaves- This is happening? or like... Well, not per se, but, but almost, right? I mean- The spirit . The spirit, you know- Vinson Cunningham: A wig-pulling spirit is Naomi Fry: at loose ... one, uh... Yes. Mm-hmm. Yes. One, um, one memorable moment from the first season that got a lot of play online is Kim Kardashian, who is one of the, the central, uh... Allura, her name is Allura. Fabio Bertoni: Mm-hmm. Naomi Fry: One of the central lawyers in, in this, in this firm, uh, wears to the office a kind of a p- a form-fitting suit. Uh-huh. But the pants are very, very low, uh, low slung- ... let's say. The slacks. Okay, yeah. The slacks are low slung, and from those slacks [00:37:00] emerges a thong. Ah. A hi- a, a thong pulled high- A high thong on the famous derriere. Yeah, Vinson Cunningham: yeah, Naomi Fry: yeah. And, and so, you know, people... I- it's... This- it's that kind of show. Amazing. And so it's just like the legal drama As an excuse for kind of like either kind of a TNA type, you know, steamy- Mm-hmm ... steamy romance and also cat fight vibe, or just like as a, as a way to showcase lifestyle, you know? Yeah. Which is where I return to my, you know, favorite, um, my childhood favorite, LA Law, which is how I learned about yuppies. Vinson Cunningham: Ah. Naomi Fry: Yuppies in Los Angeles. Yeah. You know? the beautiful people- Yeah ... in well-cut suits who have affairs and then, you know, go and showboat as a way to kind of, um, display their general prowess in life, their winning-ness. Vinson Cunningham: Yeah. Alex, you mentioned a recent re-watch. Alex Schwartz: Yeah, I was thinking about Anatomy of a Fall. I mean, I think, uh, I just wanna say, um, I'll talk about it in a second, but I think the thing about the legal drama is we've been talking about a certain kind of legal drama, especially ones ... Like, a TV show has every reason to open and close a case very quickly, and to show quick and satisfying resolution, or maybe unsatisfying resolution, and to give this impression that the pleasure of the legal drama is about the drama of the courtroom, and it is. But I think, I also think something that gets ... Like, the legal drama really can be a prism onto so many different aspects of- Mm ... character and society, and we've, we've [00:39:00] talked about some of them. But it also is about narrative and how we tell stories and how we present ourselves. Yeah. And I do think there's this sense of like, "We love legal dramas because we love to see justice served," but so many legal dramas are about the failure of justice to be served- Mm-hmm or about not having justice as a clearly defined thing. The trial has to end. Right. A ruling has to be given, but of course, that's why we have not guilty. There is no such thing as being ruled innocent. There is actually no definitive proof of anything- Right ... sometimes- Yeah ... in, in a court case. And I think some of the best legal dramas live in that ambiguity. So that's why I've been thinking about the movie Anatomy of a Fall, which is a French movie from 2023 by Justine Triet. The movie centers on a German novelist whose name is Sandra, who's played by Sandra Hüller, and her French husband, whose name is Samuel. And at the beginning of the film, Samuel falls to his death from a high part [00:40:00] of their chalet, and Sandra is accused of his murder, and a lot of the film is around the trial. And one thing that makes the film fun for, I think, an American audience especially, is that the courtroom looks nothing like what an American courtroom looks like. Yeah. There is no overruled. Fabio Bertoni: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Alex Schwartz: There is no objection. Overturned. Oh, there is no overturned. Yeah. It's just a really different kind of procedure and kind of setup. They're just talking. They're just talking, and one of the real, like, taboo-breaking things, even though it's of course standard there, but would not be standard here, is that the client is allowed to speak. She's ... There's one moment during the trial where her lawyer is characterizing her dead husband, Samuel, and she just says out loud, "That wasn't him at all." Like, whoop. If, if this was an American- thing- Yeah ... product, the lawyer would say, "Shut the fuck up." "We don't want you talking in the courtroom. What are you doing?" And the judge would be like, "Rah, rah, rah, contempt." But no, she's just kind of like- [00:41:00] Rah, rah, rah. Pen scabbard. Rah, Naomi Fry: rah, rah, rah, rah. Alex Schwartz: The real interest of the movie, I think, is the character portrayal, the way that each side, the defense and the prosecution, is very hell-bent, as for understandable reasons, on portraying the marriage a certain way, and the characters of the people in the marriage a certain way, and of the continual defiance by the client to agree to these terms. Because for her, real life is a lot more complex than it can be in a trial, and I think Anatomy of a Fall deals with that and picks apart the way that these competing stories- Mm-hmm ... are told, and even what the purpose is of telling these stories in a really interesting way. Vinson Cunningham: When we're back, we go from on-screen trials to the ones we obsess over in the real world. Critics at Large from The New Yorker will be right back[00:42:00] :: MIDROLL:: So of course we've been talking about legal drama, and it's a deep, it's a very, you know, deep genre. You could, you could spend a whole episode just naming uh, instances of it. What do you think today is the special significance or allure of, of the genre? Maybe not even on TV, like just trials generally. What is, what's, what's up? Naomi Fry: Well, I just think, okay, I, I, over the course of my time at The New Yorker, I, I wouldn't call myself a courtroom reporter. Vinson Cunningham: Well, you've done it a couple times. Naomi Fry: I've done it a couple times very briefly. Yeah, you have. Yeah. I've reported from the Ghislaine Maxwell- Mm-hmm ... trial. I reported from the Weinstein trial. Vinson Cunningham: Mm-hmm. Naomi Fry: I reported from the Stormy Daniels case. These are all very high-profile. I saw President Trump. But I wasn't in the courtroom. Vinson Cunningham: It's a, it's a special, it's a, it's a point of fascination. Yeah. Naomi Fry: It's a point of fascination, and, you know, so this is like during, [00:43:00] let's call it the l- the, the broader Trump era. The Trump era. The Trump era. Vinson Cunningham: The past decade. Yeah. Naomi Fry: And I think for me, there was a certain, um- Curiosity to see if things will go as one expects them to. And for me, you know, the only kind of comfort that I had was television, right? Vinson Cunningham: Yeah. Naomi Fry: Like, or, or movies. Like, will things in the courtroom proceed? Will order be kept? You know? Will things proceed according to, to kind of the accepted form of things? Vinson Cunningham: Yeah. Naomi Fry: I think there is, a- and I, I'm returning to that question of order. I think especially now, it's reassuring potentially, or also just, like, maybe there's an interest in reflecting this moment- Vinson Cunningham: Mm-hmm ... Naomi Fry: of, like, how do we, how do we interact now with the rule of law? Like, is [00:44:00] society, can society be defended, you know, in this, in this particular way? Yeah. Which is why I think it might be interesting for us right now potentially. Vinson Cunningham: Yeah. I think what you, it, what appeals to me about what you said is, um, yeah, it's like a lot of how to describe the era. A lot of questions are up in the air, but yet- Naomi Fry: Mm-hmm Vinson Cunningham: lack any sort of, um, sorta cathartic, Naomi Fry: um- Yeah, or clear trajectory- ... resolution, yeah ... or, Vinson Cunningham: yeah. Uh, questions are unsettled. And it does seem to me that even in real life, especially in real life, this is sometimes the function of the high-profile trial or case. Naomi Fry: Mm-hmm. Vinson Cunningham: There's, there are things happening in the culture, themes ambiently floating around. I'm thinking about the first great trial of my lifetime, which is the OJ Simpson trial, right? Race, policing, um, uh- Naomi Fry: Gender- Vinson Cunningham: Gender ... ge- gender violence ... sex- [00:45:00] Yeah ... gender violence, et cetera, all, um- Out there being discussed, but it takes the real life, um, conjunction of these themes in the form of the case to sort of, um... And this is in the, in the law, we talk about precedent, the past informing how the future might go- Naomi Fry: Mm-hmm ... Vinson Cunningham: through the sort of this crucial conflict. Um, that sometimes a high, high enough profile case can set terms for how we talk about things in the future, and also put sort of bows on things, finally help us to understand the past, give the, give us a, a moment, uh, almost like we do, like, at a funeral or something, to sort of eulogize an era and say, "That's what that was about." And we can sort of hit it right there, because to take from, um, Willem Dafoe's line in, uh, Boondock Saints, "There was a fire fight," you know? Like, all of a sudden you can- Yeah ... you can know what happened. Yeah. Alex Schwartz: Yeah. Yeah, I think, I think in, in these things that you were getting at earlier, Vinson, about seeing the big [00:46:00] issues of our day crystallized in these ways, um, like in a show like Cupertino, taking these- Yeah concerns, major earthshaking concerns about tech and putting them into a court case. The same thing happens in real life. Like, just to take very recent examples, Lindsay Clancy, her- the judge presiding over the whole Lindsay Clancy situation- Mm-hmm ... has ruled that a new trial will begin in the spring. I mean, that was a trial that I think a lot of- There's a new Vinson Cunningham: trial? Alex Schwartz: Yes. Vinson Cunningham: Ugh. Alex Schwartz: Because they, because- It was Naomi Fry: a mistrial, right? Alex Schwartz: Y- yeah. Yeah. Oh, right, right, right. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. Vinson Cunningham: Sorry. Alex Schwartz: You know, and of course, in, in the Lindsay Clancy case, hugely dramatic story that brings to the fore all these questions about women, postpartum treatment, postpartum psychosis, what the ex- like, these hidden experiences that erupted, in this case allegedly, in a very horrifying, world-shattering way for this, for this family, but have implications far beyond- Mm-hmm this one particular family. Makes total sense to me that [00:47:00] we're riveted by this. Yeah. Certainly I was, and I think the way that people interpreted this in public spaces on the internet said a lot about where we were as a society today. And actually, there was, in my perception, quite a lot of sympathy for Lindsay Clancy. Naomi Fry: Absolutely. Surprisingly so, I would say. Like, maybe. Be- just because it's such a horrific story. Yeah, I found it curious. It felt like kind of a relatively broad outpouring of understanding- Yeah, I think- ... for her situation. Alex Schwartz: Yeah, I think, I think, I think it was shining a light on something that, that is not so often talked about or spoken about, and people felt grateful for that, if not for the situation that, that brought the conversation to the fore. Russell Brand- Mm-hmm ... just sentenced in England, I think felt like another, schadenfreude is not exactly the word, but maybe, like, emotional release kind of moment. Mm-hmm. Okay, w- this, women have been heard, sexual predator put in his place. Maybe even a kind of, um- [00:48:00] conclusion in a way to the Johnny Depp, Amber Heard defamation trial- Mm. Mm-hmm ... which was an absolute total shit show. Mm-hmm. Yeah. One that actually was very divided in terms of people and their allegiances and their support. Vinson Cunningham: Yeah. Alex Schwartz: The E. Jean Carroll trial. Yes. The E. Jean Carroll suit against Trump. Vinson Cunningham: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Alex Schwartz: Or, like, we're talking about accountability, Meta being held accountable twice this year, being ordered to pay billions upon billions of dollars- Yeah to make up for wrongs. These spectacles, which are, like, semi-public, 'cause we're not all in the courtroom- Vinson Cunningham: Mm-hmm ... Alex Schwartz: but become part of public domain, we can mark time with them. Vinson Cunningham: Well, what you said about, um, Johnny Depp and, uh, Amber Heard and how divided it was did make me think that besides, like, searching for resolution, sometimes it's about enacting our antagonisms. It's like you know that there's a whole part of the country that totally disagrees with your worldview in a sort of, like, total [00:49:00] zero-sum way. It becomes almost sports in this way, where it's like, "I'm on team so-and-so. Um, I can finally have, um, a fulcrum for my disagreements and say, 'This is where I can, like, stage one world view against another.'" Um, I mean, this is, I guess, why that show was called War. Sometimes it's just about kind of entering into the state of war without having necessarily for there to be any bloodshed. It's like, "I can finally have it out." Naomi Fry: Mm-hmm. Vinson Cunningham: Yeah. Naomi Fry: Mm-hmm. I, I wonder what you think. Is there, like, when there comes a resolution on, on legal dramas, like on TV, on our screens- Mm-hmm a resolution doesn't ne- need to mean justice is necessarily served, but there's an ending- There's an end ... to a war. Is there, do you think, kind of like a bridge-building impulse in that, or no? Or maybe it depends on the text. Vinson Cunningham: It seems to me at least that, like, a, the, a legal proceeding, [00:50:00] those of us who, like, make it our business to interpret reality in one way or another, we're often, like, inventing endings- Mm-hmm Vinson Cunningham: and beginnings. We're saying, "This era started then." You know, interpretively saying, "Here's where this story started. Here's where it ended," you know, inventing flash points as a way to sort of give an illusory feel of h- uh, holism. The legal proceeding says, "Yeah, no, there was a beginning and an end." And, and it's, it's, it's in paper, so even if you disagree with it, it's, it is an objective thing that we can all point to. Even if it's just another way, it's another, uh, instance for us to continue to argue about, even if it, like, continues to be a point of contention, at least we can all say, "In the matter of so-and-so versus so-and-so, boom, ba-boom, boom, boom," with all of our, like, reality problems that we're always talking about. It is c- it- There's something. I, I don't, I don't think it's comforting, but it's at least, I think it's salutary to have some things be in black and white.[00:51:00] This has been Critics at Large. Rhiannon Corby is our senior producer. Our executive producer is Steven Valentino. Our show is mixed by Mike Kutchman, and we had engineering help today from Pran Bandy with music by Alexis Cuadrado. We're off next week for the holiday, but don't worry, we're gonna put something fun in our feed in case you need a break from eating all that turkey and pie and stuffing and cranberry, et cetera. But as always, you can find all of our episodes at newyorker.com/critics